Why Millions Rely on AI Daily—Yet Secretly Doubt Its Trustworthiness
Ever wonder why you find yourself chatting with AI tools more often than your own friends when hunting for the perfect product? It turns out, while AI is becoming the go-to guide for most shoppers—with a whopping 60% using it weekly—only a tiny slice, just 13%, actually trusts what it suggests outright. It’s like everyone’s willing to take AI’s advice, but they’re still double-checking under the hood before sealing the deal. This intriguing trust gap is where marketers need to focus, navigating the delicate dance between AI’s rising influence and consumer skepticism. Dive into the latest Klaviyo study to uncover how these mixed emotions shape buying behaviors and what it means for brands striving to make AI not just a tool, but a trusted companion. LEARN MORE.
AI is already influencing how consumers discover products and make decisions. But a new global study from Klaviyo shows something marketers should pay closer attention to: usage is rising quickly, while trust is not.
The “Klaviyo AI Persona Research,” based on a survey of nearly 8,000 consumers, found 60% now use AI tools at least weekly. At the same time, only 13% say they completely trust AI.
That gap is where the real marketing story sits.
Consumers are clearly incorporating AI into how they research and evaluate products. But they are doing so cautiously, treating AI as an input rather than an authority.
AI is influencing purchases faster than trust is growing
AI is already affecting real buying behavior.
The study found that 41% of consumers purchased a product recommended by AI within the past six months. Another 27% say AI introduced them to a product they later researched further before buying.
In other words, AI is already operating as a discovery layer.
More than one in five consumers now begin with AI tools when they want to learn something new, solve a problem or evaluate a purchase. For marketers, that means AI is increasingly acting as the first touchpoint in the customer journey.
However, trust in the technology is growing much more slowly than adoption. Consumers are using AI to narrow choices and gather ideas, but many still want to verify the results before acting on them.
Four AI personas reveal how consumers balance usage and trust
Klaviyo’s research groups consumers into four personas based on two factors: how often they use AI and how much they trust it.
AI Enthusiasts combine high usage with relatively high trust. This group represents about 26% of consumers globally and is already incorporating AI into everyday decision-making.
Among Enthusiasts, 89% say they used AI while shopping in the past six months. Even more telling, 43% report purchasing multiple products they had not previously known about because AI recommended them.
AI Evaluators also use AI frequently but approach it more cautiously. They are willing to rely on AI for research and comparisons, but they tend to validate recommendations before acting.
Together, Enthusiasts and Evaluators account for nearly 70% of consumers.
The remaining personas reflect more skepticism.
AI Skeptics understand and occasionally use AI but remain wary of how it appears in marketing and brand interactions. AI Holdouts, who make up about 21% of consumers, rarely use AI for shopping and tend to prefer human guidance when making decisions.
The key takeaway is that the divide is not simply between AI users and non-users. It is between consumers who trust AI, consumers who use it cautiously and consumers who remain skeptical.
Recommended Articles
Heavy AI users are also the quickest to criticize brands
One of the more revealing findings in the study is that the people most comfortable using AI are also the most critical of it.
Among AI Enthusiasts, 40% say they notice low-quality or generic AI-generated marketing content multiple times per week.
That suggests frequent AI users are becoming skilled at recognizing when brands rely too heavily on automation. As consumers spend more time interacting with AI tools, they also become better judges of what good outputs look like.
For marketers experimenting with generative AI in content, customer service or personalization, that dynamic raises the stakes. Poor execution may be noticed fastest by the very audience most likely to engage with AI-driven experiences.
The SEO toolkit you know, plus the AI visibility data you need.
Consumers are interacting with AI more like a conversation partner
The research also highlights how AI is changing search behavior.
Traditional search queries were typically short and keyword-driven. AI prompts are becoming longer and more contextual.
Seventy-eight percent of consumers say they include emotional or personal context in their prompts at least some of the time. Thirty percent now use eight or more words when interacting with AI systems.
The trust gap will shape the next phase of AI marketing
The findings point to a simple but important reality.
AI use is becoming mainstream, but trust is developing much more slowly.
Consumers are comfortable using AI to explore ideas, compare products and discover new options. Whether they trust the answers they receive depends on the quality and usefulness of the experience.
For marketers, that means showing up in AI-driven discovery environments is only part of the challenge.
The harder task is earning the confidence of consumers who are still deciding how much to believe in AI.
The full report can be downloaded here. (Registration required)
MarTech is owned by Semrush. We remain committed to providing high-quality coverage of marketing topics. Unless otherwise noted, this page’s content was written by either an employee or a paid contractor of Semrush Inc.
Constantine von Hoffman is senior editor of MarTech. A veteran journalist, Con has covered business, finance, marketing and tech for CBSNews.com, Brandweek, CMO, and Inc. He has been city editor of the Boston Herald, news producer at NPR, and has written for Harvard Business Review, Boston Magazine, Sierra, and many other publications. He has also been a professional stand-up comedian, given talks at anime and gaming conventions on everything from My Neighbor Totoro to the history of dice and boardgames, and is author of the magical realist novel John Henry the Revelator. He lives in Boston with his wife, Jennifer, and either too many or too few dogs.
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Google’s “preferred sources” feature allows users to customize their search results by selecting news outlets they want to see more often in the “Top Stories” section.
Related Articles
Customers second-guess after they buy. Use education, reassurance and personalization in post-purchase emails to increase trust and long-term value.
New guidance explains how the Universal Commerce Protocol powers AI-driven checkout across its platforms.
RCS is a game changer for mobile marketing. Updated with news that Apple and Google are testing cross-platform RCS encryption.
Is there a world where marketers move past silos to become ‘engagement architects,’ shifting from manual tasks to true orchestration?
